Poll Position: Safety in numbers

Our Poll Position for this week asks you to put yourself in the position of a super-joiner:


Discussion after the jump.

Once you've got super powers (not hard, I mean you just need mutant parents or a spider and some source of radiation), the difficulties really begin. What kind of costume should you wear? What kind of adventures do you want to go on? And most importantly of all, do you want to be a solo hero or would you rather join up with other like-minded folks? The people you hang out with say a lot about you, and no one wants to be the Wendy and Marvin of their universe's Super-Friends equivalent, you know? There's a reason the Defenders were never invited to Opening Night at a new ballpark, after all -- nobody wants the foul stench of Loser hanging off of them.

Bearing that in mind, here are my thoughts on the various super-team choices in the offering:

  • All-Star Squadron: A good fit for those who like living in a simpler, cleaner, purer time, the All-Star Squadron is DC's home for 1940's-era costumed crusaders. You've got a guaranteed group of truly deserving enemies to beat the crap out of (no one ever got pelted with rotten vegetables for shooting Nazis, after all), and a great buy-low opportunity on the Japanese stock market. Most of the people on the team were good-natured and fine teammates, as well, as you'd expect from the nostalgic view of How Things Used To Be.
  • Alpha Flight: On the one hand, you have hands-down the best-designed team uniforms out there. On the other hand, you have to live in Canada. I kid, I kid! As Kathleen Madigan said, Canada is like the United States' attic. Once you remember to poke your head in there, you're all "Man, it's a lot bigger than I remember, and look at all this cool stuff!" Plus, if things go too horribly wrong, you can call on the RCMP. Ahem.
  • Avengers: The undoubted king of super teams, with all the prestige and renown that implies. You get your own mansion, your own robot butler system (which only occasionally tries to kill you all in your sleep), god-like (literally) teammates, super fancy jets, top-secret government clearance so you can finally expunge that embarrassing item from your Permanent Record, etc.
  • Bureau for Paranormal Research and Defense (BPRD): Getting to hang out with Hellboy would be fun, as I'm pretty sure he gets all those beers for free. However, you would constant be running around fighting slimy things that could steal your soul. If you've got an affinity for horror stuff, this is the best choice.
  • Green Lantern Corps: Interstellar travel, good health benefits ("We even bring you back after you're dead! Several times!"), cool costumes, and awesome powers. This is a pretty attractive group, were it not for their habit of getting completely annihilated from time to time.
  • Guardians of the Globe: From the pages of "Invincible", I mostly have this on the list because I wanted an option for people who want to be part of a team that not only will be killed to the last man (see Corps, Green Lantern), but in the bloodiest, messiest, most gore-festooned way possible. Because that's how I roll.
  • Justice League: The kings of the DC Universe, with all the perks that implies. Big space-borne satellite station, teleportation wherever you want to go, Superman backing you up, there's lots to like here. However, they seem like they'd have a lot of rules. And you have "Watch Hours" which is irritating any time after college and you're no longer an RA. I bet Batman doesn't have to sit there in front of the computer playing Solitaire and hoping nothing blows up in Namibia. Plus, have you seen some of the hosers they let in this group?
  • Legion of Super-Heroes: I'd love to see the future. On the down side, Matter Eater Lad might take a fancy to your iPod for a between-meals snack, which is never fun.
  • X-Men: You have to have mutant powers, your boss can read your mind ("That's not an educational film you're downloading and we both know it."), everyone not a mutant wants to kill you, and every adventure ends in some kind of misery. No thanks. Plus I wouldn't want to have to put up with cleaning out the drain after The Beast showers, that's just gross y'all.

So, looking over the list, you have to say that prestige-wise, the Justice League and the Avengers come out clearly on top. But, if you like space travel and sci-fi stuff, the GL Corps and the Legion are strong contenders, just as the All-Star Squadron is for your Golden Age types and the BPRD for horror fans. Since I'm a fan of the powers, the costumes, and the mission, I'd probably go with the GL Corps. I like that they don't need fancy machines to do all their work, that they get to see space, and that if you line up all their enemies you get a pretty rainbow.

How about you, what team would you want to be part of?

21 Responses to Poll Position: Safety in numbers

  1. John says:

    The Avengers, hands down. But that may just be the 1980s Marvel fanboy in me talking.

  2. John says:

    …though Alpha Flight would be pretty cool, but only if it was John Byrne’s AF, from say, his first 18 or so issues of the original series.

  3. Jose Inoa says:

    Dang… I really, really like the BPRD. But, I voted for joining the All-Star Squadron because, hey same mystical baddies to beat down, and “Uncle Sam” at the lead. All-Star Squadron, all the way.

  4. The Imp says:

    I think there is more chance of scoring super-babe ass with the X-Men, so yeah….


  5. DJ says:

    Avengers. I would prefer West Coast version but any version would rock.

  6. Jeff Hebert says:

    Even the Great Lakes Avengers, DJ? 🙂

  7. Danny Beaty says:

    I’d probably end up in The Mystery Men.

  8. Hammerknight says:

    All-Star all the way, back when Heroes were heroes, and all that good stuff. Back with all the original heroes.Back when the term “Mystery Men” was a good thing, meaning all the super heroes. Back when it had all the JSA as members. Great comics. Give me the old style comics any day oversome of the stuff today.

  9. tristan says:

    Who is uncle sam???? and i voted for Bureau for Paranormal Research and Defense because i love hellboy.

  10. Tigerguy786 says:

    Justice League, with no hesitation. Batman and Superman as buddies? Yes please! Plus how cool would it be to work in a satellite above the earth?

    Nowadays, almost every single DC hero is up there. That is awesome. There are a lot of interesting characters in the DC universe.

  11. Timespike says:

    BPRD. Why? Because those people actively CARE about each other. That’s less of a superteam and more of a family with government funding.

  12. William A. Peterson says:

    I know you have the All Stars on there, but what happened to the JSA? They were there first!
    I picked the Green Lantern Corps, but, really, JSA is what I wanted!

  13. darkvatican says:

    All Star Squadron for me! By the way, did anybody ever notice why they never call the squadron by an acronym like JLA or JSA? it’s always made me chuckle…

  14. Kalkin says:

    Why aren’t my two favorites – Authority and Superhomeys – included?

  15. Amathakathi says:

    BPRD is definitely the best team up there. Literally the most colorful characters plus some really cool guns and gizmos to play with.
    But as you pointed out: the Earth is about to be annihilated every day, your backup doesn’t tend to last more than a few panels and you’re generally not allowed out in public. I think even X-men had better perks in comparison.
    Worst of all is really the fact that the team is more prone to breaking up than a teenager’s voice at the prom.
    At one point, Hellboy was in Africa, Abe was rediscovering his past, Liz was abducted by Ming the Merciless, Roger is dead, Captain Daimio turned into a jaguar and disappeared, Kate got kidnapped by phantasmal malefic art-collectors, Tanya is still bed-ridden, leaving Johann as the only active member of the team. He then was possessed by german scientists.
    Certainly never a dull moment!

  16. Hammerknight says:

    @William A. Peterson at one time the JSA was part of the All Stars.

  17. Jeff Hebert says:

    I always thought of the JSA as just the earlier version of the JLA, and since I already had the JLA, I wanted something more distinct.

  18. Mr. Q says:

    Avengers, pre Bendis of course (screw that bald, no talent prick).

  19. kingmonkey says:

    Alpha Flight. I’m Canadian, so I could avoid the immigration hassles. Plus, there’s a greater chance that I’d be the coolest member of the team.

  20. I picked the Green Lantern Corps. Because I’ve always been enamoured of the light constructs, and because I look good in green.

    (They ought to do a series of scifi short stories about Lanterns on other worlds. Something kinda like Star Wars Tales.)

  21. Al says: