For the first time in HeroMachine contest history, we have a second-time winner. Congratulations to xStacy for his winning entry for Caption Contest 18!

Other honorable mentions included:
Bajonk: American Gothic, millenium edition. (again, I'm a sucker for a good fine art reference)
Bajonk: Someone call a babysitting service?
Doomed Pixel: Hi, my name is Phil, and I divided by zero.
Wild Ferret King: Worst. Vacation. EVER.
Ian: “Pestilence is home sick, so we’re just the Three Horsemen of the Apocalypse tonight.”
Many thanks to everyone who submitted one of the record-breaking number of entries this week, your good humor and creativity are much appreciated. xStacy has won a second black and white custom illustration of whatever he likes; check back in a bit for your own chance to win the same with Caption Contest 19!
Um, that “EnderX” quote is actually mine…
Whoops, sorry Pixel! I’ll fix it. I cut and pasted them all in and had to cut out the extra bits, and cut out too much.
Thanks for correcting it.
that was funny…cake is always funny, heehee cake
Holy crap, I gotta start checking my e-mail more often. Once again, I learn I won by reading the entry!
you know this looks like Ghost Rider and Batman went back to the midevil days and teamed up with skeletor