Caption Contest 49: Keep 'em punchy

Some things just go naturally together, like peanut butter and jelly, Oreos and milk, Simon and Garfunkle and -- of course -- Tuesdays and Caption Contests. That's right, it's time once again to see if you can come up with the best replacement dialog for this comic book panel, and thereby win your very own custom black and white illustration of whatever you like (within reason) from professional artist Jeff Hebert:


The rules are simple: leave your entry in the comments to this post; no more than three entries per person; and keep it relatively clean.

Good luck, everyone! Oh, and special thanks go to Cory for suggesting this panel be used for a caption contest, and to HalLoweEn JacK for promising to giggle if I used it. That's motivation we can believe in, my friends!

78 Responses to Caption Contest 49: Keep 'em punchy

  1. Avatar amathakathi says:

    1. You have something on your face. I’ll get it — oops…

    2. Hey you’re not Batman!

    3. They just don’t make villains like they used to. Look how flimsy he is!

  2. Avatar DJ says:

    1. See how it looks like my fist is going through his head? Thanks Big Al’s Joke shop!

    2.Extreme Lobotomy only 25 cents!


  3. Avatar Gregg says:

    Welcome to the party! Have some PUNCH!

  4. Avatar RJ McD says:

    who you calling rocky now?

  5. Avatar Cory says:

    1. I said LEGGO MY EGGO!

    2. Do you exfoliate?

    3. Wonder Twin Powers Activa…oops

  6. Avatar miggo says:

    1) Everybody was Kung-Fu fighting.. tibby-tibby-tib-tib tib-tib ty

    2) Talk to the hand!

    3) Tag! You’re it!

  7. Avatar hookman says:

    Oops,my hand slipped!

  8. Avatar James says:

    1. TAG!

    2. I said I’d GLADLY pay you TUESDAY!

    3. That’s for having a beartrap on your shoulder!

  9. Avatar TheNate says:

    1. Take a closer look at my pinky ring!

    2. Hold still – there’s a mosquito on your nose.

  10. Avatar Spillman says:

    1. Will that grow back?
    2. Pick up your trash
    3. whats the matter fist got your tongue?

  11. Avatar Syzyx says:

    1) How dare you wear my colours here!

    2) You put your whole fist in…

    3) And that’s for making off with the background, Liefeld!

  12. Avatar Steve says:

    1. SPIDER!!!

    2. Nothing stops the Cole Train baby!

    3. HA! Rock beats paper!

  13. Avatar Rick says:

    1. Give me. Back. My Bubblegum.

    2. I said look where I am pointing, ass!

    3. Got yer nose! (Recycled comment but I like it here too)

  14. Avatar im a freak! says:

    why am i hitting you again?

  15. Avatar Solander says:

    1. I punch Emo Kids!

    2. You should have that hole in your head checked out.

    3. I wish you were dead… and NOT just because I am a necrophiliac.

  16. Avatar Eric says:

    “Gaze into the fist of Dredd!”

    Whoah, wait…

  17. Avatar Danny Beaty says:

    1. I strongly disagree!

    2. Let me give you a hand!

    3. INCOMING!

  18. Avatar John says:

    oooo…Steve’s #3 made me literally laugh out loud. Well done!

  19. Avatar deadeas says:


    2) Hmm…I wonder how you get brain off a gauntlet…

    3) There…Now you can breath without that pesky face in the way!

  20. Avatar deadeas says:

    Hehehe…Loving these captions…Syzyx’s third caption made me laugh especially.

  21. Avatar Jester says:

    1. Welcome to Old Navy!

    2. I think I’ll get a second opinion…

    3. You blinked.

  22. Avatar Frankie says:

    “Oh! Oh my god! I’m so sorry. I just wanted to see if I could punch a dent in your helmet.”

  23. Avatar Frankie says:

    “Fist goes in, guts come out…..brains come out.”

  24. Avatar Frankie says:

    “No. I’m the strong arm of the law.”

  25. Avatar HalLoweEn JacK says:

    1. ..oops…
    2. I HATE people with a glass jaw!

  26. takes 5 licks to get to the center of the tootsie pop! got something on your nose
    3.lets see what your thinking

  27. Avatar John D says:

    1. “Jumanji!”

    2. “Punch Buggy Red!”

    3. “I said..NO ONIONS!!!!!”

  28. Avatar Moonshade says:

    There’s something in your eye…

  29. Avatar Niall Mor says:

    Hey! I found your contact lens! See?

    No, you get your face out of my fist.

  30. Avatar purple_phoenix says:

    “Let me get that fly for you. Now hold still.”

  31. Avatar HalLoweEn JacK says:

    *Illegal 4th Entry*

    Leave ME off the Caption Contest leadersboard, will you?!?

  32. Avatar HalLoweEn JacK says:

    * and if possible, I’d like to insert the word ‘HAPPY’ into my 3rd legitimate entry as follows,


  33. Avatar Whit says:

    Dang, you guys beat me to the “punch” with the ideas I had.

  34. Avatar Whit says:

    1) And this is where your cerebral cortex is!

  35. Avatar The D-Man says:

    How dare you say that Santa Claus isn’t real!!

  36. Blue Blazer Blue Blazer says:

    1) Door knob!
    2) My MOTHER made these shoulder pads!

  37. Avatar Ian says:

    1. I…am…duh law!

    2. Someday I’ll be played by Stallone!

    3. Citizen, you have a booger.

  38. Avatar HalLoweEn JacK says:

    I don’t know if this is legal, but if I can PLEASE change one of my entries – preferrably the first one – then I’d like to wwithdraw “…oops…” and relace it with;

    “Ann Coulter, you have been judge… what the…?! Empty!”

  39. Avatar TheNate says:

    3. Head-on! Apply directly to head!

  40. Avatar machines says:

    My favorite hero was Kaliman

  41. Avatar Cory says:

    I told you that this would be a good pic for a caption contest!

  42. Avatar Zorbas The Awesome says:


    *lol srry Jeff i had to and liefield SUCKS*


    *300 ANYONE!!!!*


  43. Avatar Jose Inoa says:

    [1] Punch-buggy – DEATH!
    [2] Fancy helmets can’t obstruct JUSTICE!
    [3] I don’t – use – STEROIDS!

  44. Kaldath Kaldath says:

    You Put your right fist in, you take your right fist out, you put your right fist in and the brains all pour out!

  45. Avatar Richard Tale says:

    1 – Ups… I think you need surgery now…

    2 – I SAID YAHTZEE!!

    3 – This is for making fun of my costume. AND CLOSE THE DOORS!

  46. Kaldath Kaldath says:

    One of These Days Alice POW right in the kisser!!

  47. Avatar Pyrate Hyena says:

    I didnt know i could do that!

    Darling how could you? I thought this was about trust!

  48. Avatar Bael says:

    1) And I thought “In one ear and out the other” was just a blond joke.

    2) Look Ma! No brains!

  49. Avatar Tal says:

    Not sure if I’m on the safe side with this, but:

    1. Now THAT’s “Fisting”!

  50. Avatar bearfoot says:

    Gotcher nose!

  51. Avatar DJ says:

    *if I can Id like to change my number 3 entry to this*

    3.THE CAKE WAS A LIE (for more info look back to

  52. Avatar Loki says:

    1.(singing) I’ve got eye of the tiger!


    3.Don’t worry! I’m a brain surgeon!

  53. Avatar Loki says:

    oops…. one is (singing) I’ve got the eye of the tiger!

  54. Avatar EnderX says:

    “Our testers rated this helmet 0 out of 10.”

  55. Avatar Ballin' Boy says:

    Haha I got your nose. Oops

  56. Avatar Ballin' Boy says:

    you know scratch that one didn’t realize others already used it (this is a request not an entry)

  57. Avatar Ballin' Boy says:

    One look? ONE LOOK?!!!

  58. Avatar Ballin' Boy says:

    Ohh Look at that house behind yo….ooops

  59. Kaldath Kaldath says:

    My Number 3 ) YES! All those hours playing Punch out on the NES finally paid off!

  60. Avatar William A. Peterson says:

    “I already told you… Don’t be so VIOLENT!”

  61. Avatar Socrates says:

    Entry 1. Can you hear me now?

  62. Avatar thunder 2000 says:

    1. Overruled!!!

    2. How many times do I have to tell you, KEEP IT SHUT!!!

    3. This is my long arm of the law

  63. Avatar Cory says:

    Hey Jeff, I thought because I suggested this panel (already having a caption in mind) that it’d be easy pickins,but there are some good entries here, like Steve’s #3, I dont think anything comes close to that one….

  64. Avatar Jeff Hebert says:

    Agreed, Cory, there are some stellar ones in here, I credit your vision in seeing it would make a good panel šŸ™‚

  65. Avatar Damien says:

    1] Hey! Where’s the cream filling?!
    2] Boba Fett is NOT my mother! Take it back!
    3] How DARE you try and copy my shoulder-thingie?!

  66. Avatar Tal says:

    My safer other two:

    2. KIIII-AI!
    (Imagine: karate-style brick-breaking)

    3. No! Armor Suite #2 can’t be empty!

  67. Avatar Niall Mor says:

    Now hold still, Mr. Johnson. This may sting a little.

  68. Avatar Ballin' Boy says:

    Dredd’s love is like Dredd’s law. Hard and fast.

  69. Avatar Abron Hester says:

    SIR! Please stop eating my fist!

  70. Avatar Ronin Kai says:

    ( is it me ore did some of these post get copied over or something …. oh well here goes )

    1: Told you i could fit my entire fist into your mouth!

    2: Sorry new helmet …. ahh man not again.

    3: I am not a robo-cop rip-off!!!

  71. Avatar Brad says:

    Alrighty, let’s take a stab at this

    1. TAKE THA-oh..oh god…i just meant to punch you..

    2. That’s for making me open doors to see your face!

    3. Rectum? Damn near killed ’em
    (it’s a punchline…get it?)

  72. Avatar Joshy676 says:

    1. Excuse me, but my right to throw punches needs an extension through the back of your skull.

    2. I’ve heard of knuckle sandwiches but THIS is ridiculous!

    3. How ’bout a sammich?

  73. Avatar JonnyDemon says:

    1. I love my momma very much, now you know that too!!! 2. Now you don’t have to worry about flossing! 3.Dahling, dragon winged helmuts are so 80’s, try this instead.

  74. Avatar Brad Carter says:

    1.Suck my thunder fist!!!

    2.There that should’ve fixed your speach inpedament!!!

    3.Compliments of Captain Insano!!!

  75. Avatar von Bek says:

    1. I’m gonna have to confiscate these brains citizen.

    2. Now look upon the face of the law!

    3. Simon Cowell is NOT the best Judge ever!

    Illegal 4th.

    I laugh in the face of Death.

  76. Avatar Jason says:

    1) Insert punch line here? Hope this counts!

    2) This will shut Judge Judy up about who’s tougher!

    3) eeew, squishy.

  77. Avatar Danny Beaty says:

    Who won the caption contest?